A Complete Guide on the Best Cotton Sheets

Long-staple cotton: For peak coziness, experts recommend looking for options made with long-staple cotton. "The longer the staple—which literally refers to how long the individual cotton fibers are—the smoother the feel," says Amy Hoban, chief creative officer at Parachute. "Shorter fibers are more likely to break and feel nubbly, which makes for a rougher, less durable sheet. Long-staple cotton produces fabric that’s softer and more resistant to pilling and wear over time." As a result, most of the picks in our roundup are classified this way by their manufacturers.

Fabric finish: "How a fabric is finished can dramatically change the handfeel—what it actually feels like against your skin," notes Hoban. "Brushed cotton, for instance, is softer than a crisp percale—think buttery-soft versus smooth-soft." Fischer adds, "a flannel is always better for cooler weather and has a more casual, cozy feel."

Fabric weave: Two of the most common cotton weaves are percale and sateen. The weave determines the sheet’s texture, warmth, and breathability; choosing between the two really comes down to personal preference. "Percale is a simple one-over-one weave that results in a crisp, cool sheet with a matte finish. It’s breathable, durable, and perfect for year-round use—especially for hot sleepers," says Hoban. "Sateen, meanwhile, features a four-over-one weave that creates a silky, smooth texture with a gentle sheen and elegant drape." If you prefer a slightly warmer, heavier fabric with a more luxurious handfeel, sateen is your best bet.

Functional details: "Practical details like strong stitching, deep pockets for larger mattress depths, and even reviews on how the bedding holds up in the wash over time are also big indicators of quality," says Fischer.

Avoid synthetic blends: "While these can be more affordable, they lack the breathability and longevity of natural fibers—qualities that are essential for better sheets and years of better sleep," notes Hoban.